The building's slow elevator earned my denture work a single star

This account was submitted by a healthcare provider and de-identified before publication. Details that could identify a patient or practice have been removed, and it is shared with the provider’s consent.

What was posted

The review complained almost entirely about the building's elevator being slow and cramped. The writer described waiting several minutes for the elevator and feeling frustrated before even reaching my third-floor office. They mentioned the stairwell was tucked away and hard to find. Only at the very end did they note that their denture fitting had gone smoothly and they were satisfied with the result. Despite that, they left a single star, driven by the elevator and the building layout. My practice does not own or manage the building, let alone the elevator. It was strange to see careful denture work rated on the performance of the property's machinery.

What actually happened

The key fact is that the reviewer said the denture fitting went smoothly, which is the clinical outcome that counts. The elevator and building layout are managed by the property owner, entirely outside my practice's control. I cannot speed up the elevator or relocate the stairwell. I understand the frustration of a slow elevator, particularly for older patients coming for denture care. But the quality of that care is separate from the building's infrastructure. My team delivered a satisfactory fitting, as the review itself acknowledges. A one-star rating on elevator speed misrepresents the service prospective patients would actually receive. That is the disconnect I find hard to accept.

Impact

On Healthgrades, the star average shapes first impressions, regardless of whether the gripe was about an elevator. Denture patients skew older and often depend on ratings when choosing a provider. It was frustrating to have twenty-one years of careful work rated on building logistics I cannot change. I felt a quiet unfairness knowing the actual care was praised in the same breath as the one star. There is a helplessness in being penalized for a landlord's aging elevator. I care about accessibility, so the complaint bothered me even though it was not about my dentistry. The emotional part was a lingering sense of being judged on the wrong thing.

Steps taken

I raised the elevator concern with the building's property management, since accessibility genuinely matters to me. I asked whether Healthgrades would consider the review off-topic, though I braced for it to remain. I did not respond publicly in a defensive tone, which would not have helped. I improved signage inside the building to make my office easier to find. I offered to help less-mobile patients coordinate arrival times to avoid delays. I added clear directions to my appointment reminders. I reminded myself that building logistics are outside my clinical control. Advocating for a better elevator was the most useful thing I could actually do.

Reported impact on this provider

Emotional DistressReputation Damage

Three others reported Reputation Damage

See all 173 →

Three Profiles, One Fabricated Story

All other dentists had given up on her and told her she needed all of her teeth pulled and needed dentures. She was young and wanted to try…

Read what happened →

She Named Me Everywhere—and I Had No Way to Defend Myself

She originally said she was upset because the doctor had removed a failing implant and didn’t want to pay for it. I asked her what I could…

Read what happened →

A False Criminal Accusation That Nearly Destroyed the Practice

The patient, an unhealthy, obese, entitled female was treated for a simple tooth extraction. She was prescribed a standard regimen of…

Read what happened →

Add your voice to the record

Behind every story is a career that deserved better.

If you have been affected, adding your story to the record is one of the most important contributions you can make to this campaign. Legislators read these accounts.

Every submission is de-identified before publication. Your privacy — and your patients’ — is protected.