Over a few days our Facebook rating plummeted from 4.9 to 4.1

This account was submitted by a healthcare provider and de-identified before publication. Details that could identify a patient or practice have been removed, and it is shared with the provider’s consent.

What was posted

Over a few days our Facebook rating plummeted from 4.9 to 4.3 and falling, as a wave of nasty one-star reviews — many with no comment — appeared.

What actually happened

I checked every reviewer name against our patient database. Only one was an actual patient: a mother with a poor show rate who had been warned per our no-show protocol and ultimately dismissed. The rest were names from her Facebook network, several living more than three hours away, none of whom had ever set foot in our practice.

Impact

A rapid, alarming drop in our public rating. My partner and I had to weigh carefully how to respond without provoking something worse.

Steps taken

Facebook's guidelines offered no recourse. I chose not to respond, fearing escalation. We eventually turned reviews off, which hid the ratings but didn't erase them and blocked new reviews. Google and other platforms can't be handled the same way, and there's no recourse for an innocent practice.

Reported impact on this provider

Reputation DamageStaff Impact

Three others reported Reputation Damage

See all 176 →

He Refused the ER—and His Family Believed We Sent Him Home

Pt with chief concern of urinary retention. He had obvious evidence of head trauma on exam (abrasions and a black eye if I recall…

Read what happened →

She Requested an Unnecessary Exam. I Couldn’t Explain Why I Refused.

The patient requested an exam that was not appropriate for her age. I declined to perform the exam she requested.

Read what happened →

False Reviews, Legal Threats, and Thoughts of Early Retirement

The post was not accurate. The patient presented with severe, rapidly progressing dental disease and repeatedly delayed or declined…

Read what happened →

Add your voice to the record

Behind every story is a career that deserved better.

If you have been affected, adding your story to the record is one of the most important contributions you can make to this campaign. Legislators read these accounts.

Every submission is de-identified before publication. Your privacy — and your patients’ — is protected.